Name: Halloween Sherbet Punch
Prep time: 5 min
Total time: 5 min
Yield: 20
Ingredients: 2 liter Orange Soda, chilled; 46 ounce Pineapple Juice, chilled; 48 ounce Orange Sherbet; Gummy Marshmallows (for garnish); Gummy Worms (for garnish)

Pin1

1 Shares

This post may contain affiliate links. Please read my full disclosure policy.

Jump to Recipe

Updated on February 12, 2025

Halloween Sherbet Punch Recipe. With only three ingredients, this frothy orange Halloween punch is sure to be the hit of the party!

I like to make punch for every party we have. My go-to party punch recipe can be made in any color and is the one I make most often, but sometimes, I want to make something different.

This Halloween sherbet punch has only three ingredients and comes together easily.

This punch is great for Halloween parties, bridal showers, baby showers, anniversary parties, and birthdays.

This recipe will make approximately 20 one-cup servings.

TABLE OF CONTENTS

Ingredients:

Orange Soda, chilled
Pineapple Juice, chilled
Orange Sherbet
Candy Eyeballs (for garnish)
Gummy Worms (for garnish)

What Type of Soda to Use

I used Orange Fanta for this recipe, but you can substitute any orange soda brand.

If the recipe seems too sweet, use lemon-lime soda, ginger ale, or even seltzer water instead of the orange soda. If you choose one of these options, the color of the punch will be a little less orange.

Do I Have to Use Pineapple Juice?

If you don’t like or are allergic to pineapple juice, you can substitute orange juice or lemonade. However, the flavor and color will be different.

How to Make Halloween Sherbet Punch

This easy Halloween punch recipe comes together so quickly. Add the orange soda and pineapple juice to a punch bowl or large pitcher.

Top the soda and pineapple mixture with scoops of orange sherbet. Use an ice cream scooper for this step.

Garnish with marshmallow gummy eyeballs and worms. Set the gummy worms on the outside of the punch bowl, as they will quickly sink if you add them to the punch.

Don’t stir, but use a ladle to serve the punch. You want to keep the sherbet as solid as possible.

RELATED: More Delicious Drink Recipes

What Type of Punch Bowl Should I Use

You can make this punch in any punch bowl or pitcher. However, a pitcher makes pouring the sherbet more difficult, so I recommend a large punch bowl.

Any large bowl will work. You can use a punch bowl, large salad, or trifle bowl.

Helpful Tips

When making this for a party, prepare the soda and pineapple mixture ahead and add the sherbet and garnishes at the last minute.
Add more scoops of sherbet as they get used up if you like.
Chill the soda and pineapple juice before serving. This way, the sherbet won’t melt as fast.
Use ginger ale and vanilla ice cream to make this punch less sweet.
For adults, you can add alcohol to the punch. Flavored vodka, regular vodka, or white rum are all good additions.
For a fun way to serve, dip the edge of individual cups in water and coat the top of the glass with Halloween sprinkles.
Any sherbet flavor will work for this punch, but the taste and look of the punch will change. Rainbow sherbet is the easiest flavor to find and works great.

More Halloween Drink Recipes:

Printable Recipe